Skip to main content

Google Reader's demise levels the playing field

Google Reader Farewell
Way back in March, Google revealed plans to shut down eight of its services as part of what it calls an ongoing spring cleaning effort. I was pretty bummed to see that Google Reader will be shut down on July 1. Yes, Google Reader my most used app on web is history now. This is one web app(in simple terms it could get a list of all the recent "new stuff" that a site or a user or a channel has published, so you don't have to go anywhere, every new thing came inside Reader), that will be remembered by me forever, it made me the regular reader that I've become by using it almost everyday since last 7-8 yrs.

My first reaction was: How am I going to work now?
I use Google Reader every day to aggregate and filter news, analysis and research. I cannot begin to tell you how big a difference Reader made to my work flow by saving so much time and effort. Almost every blog, technology website has a RSS(Real Simple Syndication) feed, and I had a great heaping bucket of them in Reader. Being able to go to one place instead of many, enabled me to scan so many more articles in so much less time. Plus, Reader allowed me to search back in old posts. I can’t count the number of times I thought, “I remember reading that in a blog, but not which one” and found it by searching Reader.

I’ve also seen some people argue that we don’t need Reader in the age of social media. Why get an RSS feed when the hivemind recommends the good stuff? Where do you think the hivemind finds the stuff to recommend? From nerds who are monitoring their RSS feeds. I am often aware of stuff in my feed days before I start seeing recommendations on Twitter. In essence, Twitter is a big RSS reader, allowing you to “follow” the people sharing content that you’d like to consume. But, Twitter is realtime and RSS is time-shifted. That simple concept of following gripped, but subscribing to feeds simply did not. Because RSS as a technology is too nerdy, too behind-the-scenes and lacked general consumer appeal.

Google Reader started in 2005 at what was really the golden age of RSS, blogging systems and a new content ecosystem. And it entered the market with big ideas, a clear, clean slate and captured the imagination of early adopters. Reader was great because it centralized a lot of features that made RSS much better for users — you could organize stuff into folders and it would remember what you had and hadn't read,  plus you could easily save and share articles. It also provided a way for apps to sync those features — so if I read something with Press on Android, I wouldn't have to see it again on Reeder on iPad.

Since I had to be in a state of getting used to life without Reader eventually, I’ve been looking at alternatives for last few months. Though, I've started using Feedly lately, I haven't finalized yet, which one I'll use in long term, but Feedly is a strong contender and so is Digg Reader. Considering, Digg was the mother of my online discovery, and it was through it that I landed on sites like LifehackerTechcrunchGigaom, which became my daily drivers since then.

I'll miss Google Reader, like many other power users. There is a pretty sizable pocket of people(bloggers, journalists, researchers – edge cases in our news consumption behaviors) like us who are upset at Reader’s demise and unfortunately for us, Google is not the right company for niche services. Google wants to create products  that fulfill its core missions: search, social, ads and are used by hundreds of million of users and Google Reader wasn't one of them. But allowing it to sit out there, neglected and yet still functional, was at least a comfort to this niche crowd, where Reader still served as one of the company’s most-used apps of all time, right up there with Gmail. Reader was for information junkies; not just tech nerds. This market totally exists and is weirdly under-served (and is possibly affluent). But this group, though small, are some of the web’s most engaged users. They are the people building its pieces and underpinnings, and filling it with content. As The Guardian aptly put it, killing Reader is like killing the bees. The damage to the ecosystem extends beyond the hundreds of thousands, or millions rather, impacted directly by Google Reader’s death.

Unfortunately, the idea of RSS was one that never quite gripped with normal Internet users. Sure, for us geeks who absolutely love consuming as much information as possible, RSS is a wonderland. There simply isn't a better substitute for RSS if you want to collate a wide variety of content in one place.

Reader's demise, levels the playing field in the feed reading world. Now there are more competitors, more innovation, there are new platforms for distributing feeds, new interfaces. Suddenly, feed readers are a hot topic. Until now, Google Reader was the dominant service and platform, but they didn't know what to do with it. Reader stopped adding new features back in 2010 and it was in maintenance mode since then. Few dared to challenge its position and most new feed readers were only Reader clients.

Reader's disappearance is Google's best idea for saving RSS. From stagnant to vibrant in 3 months. Reader's demise helped RSS more, than the last 3 years of silence. Some people think that Reader could've been successful if Google promoted it more. The truth is that Google Reader was more than just a feed reader, it was probably the most well-connected Google service. No other Google product benefited from so many service integrations.

Missed opportunities

I wonder, did Google and the ecosystem at large misread the tea leaves? Did the world at large see a RSS/reader market when in reality the actual market opportunity was in data and sentiment analysis?

If there were things that went wrong, then there is a lot of positive things that came from Google Reader. One of the main reasons why Reader could exist was because companies and entities with conflicting agendas came together to support RSS and other standards. Google, MoveableTypeBloggerWordPressFlickr and several other web apps believed in creating RSS feeds for easy consumption. In the end it helped the average users.

But all that is behind us and we might not see similar altruism again. If in the early 2000s, Web 2.0 companies were building platforms that wanted to work with each other, today we have platforms that are closed.

We live in the world of information silos now. Twitter and Instagram have broken up. Facebook is the walled garden of the modern web. There is no common language of sharing and new systems don’t offer RSS. And rightfully so! And unless we have web giants speaking the same language of sharing, there seems to be no future of aggregation.

Killing Google Reader isn't the same thing as killing the open web, but the open web isn't something we should take for granted. We should fight for it, and we should fight for RSS to continue as a part of it. Maybe it's time to get a better Reader, even if not from Google.

Popular posts from this blog

Roko mat Toko mat

Bachpan se bada koi school nahi, curiosity se badi koi teacher nahi.
There is no greater school than childhood and no greater teacher than curiosity.

Parle G(the largest selling brand of biscuits in the world) asks parents to encourage their child's curiosity and creativity in its campaign called 'Kal ke genius'. While the song has an '80s feel, it is the soul of the film and is written, sung and composed very well. The song aptly encapsulates the philosophy of the campaign. It is urging people to let their kids be just kids and let them explore if they are curious.

Parle-G's Glucose biscuits always evoke a sense of nostalgia. The ad in a nice way talks about the increasing parental control and societal pressures that make kids these days spend more time in study classes than learning through exploring new things. Curiosity is actually the best teacher. Unfortunately, it is just the kind of a thing which parents often discourage. In fact, we keep stopping children fro…

Wedding Cum Reception Card

Hi Everybody,
Well somedays back I got a request from one of my friend that I should make the invitation card for his wedding cum reception. Well I was shocked to know that my friends perceive that I am a designer too. I am quite thankful for this perception of you all people but I feel sorry to say that I don't have any designing skills. So I just finalised with him that I am ready to write the content for your card but not the design,& thank God he agreed, as according to him I have a good content writing skills. So I just wanted to verify from you people that whatever I have written is perfect enough for him. As he is my one of good friends so I don't want any problems with it. So please help me to make it a success. And pls. do not copy it for any of your friends as I have already patented it from USA PATENT CO.

AKASH Weds VANI
Venue: All India Radio Station.
Special Attraction: This is a Marriage.
Instruction Manual: Do read before coming.
1. We request you to please come,p…

I'm Deepak Ravlani, and This Is How I Work

Like so many heroes of the startup world, I started early after college. Now, with years of experience in Technology behind me, it has become a lot easier to polish my workflow and get lots of stuff done. Let's talk about my workspace setup, go-to apps, best life hacks, favorite gadgets and tunes. In my free time, I work on a few side projects, including Blogging and managing several communities over Google+. Since launching in Dec 2012, +Project Glass community has become one of the fastest growing community. With  more than 2500(and counting) users and a thriving community of Glass fans, needless to say, the past few months have been crazy for me. Last time I went through this, it was 2008. I was using different apps, but did have sort of productivity system that really helped me get things done. In last few years, I've picked up a few tips and tricks along the way and I've been making some small changes here and there as I get more comfortable with my flow, So this time…

Next big thing for Smartphone's: Seeing And Understanding

A Smartphone would be able to see and understand its environment with the help of Perceptual Computing And Vision Processing.

Project Tango, an attempt to give mobile devices human-like understanding of space and motion by +Google ATAP(Advanced Technology And Projects).

Computer vision is a rich field of academic, commercial and industrial research, the implications of which extend tendrils into virtually every aspect of our lives. Anticipating needs before they arise, and understanding needs that a person might not even be aware they have, make up the broader blue sky opportunities for a tech like this.

Perceptual computing encompasses the whole field of analyzing data captured with sensors and visualization systems like cameras and infrared light. Computer vision is one component of the field, which allows devices to ‘see’ the areas around it more like a human does — or better. Getting 3D sensing onto phones, and spatial and topographic contextual awareness is table stakes for the n…

Google's Augmented Reality Glass: Project Glass

After months of speculation, Google revealed some information(on April 4th, 2012 to be specific)
about the Project Glass. Instead of using a smartphone to find information about an object, translate a text, get directions, compare prices, you can use smart glasses that augment the reality and help you understand more about things around you. Google says "We think technology should work for you—to be there when you need it and get out of your way when you don't. A group of us from Google[x] started Project Glass to build this kind of technology, one that helps you explore and share your world, putting you back in the moment".

Since, it has been more than a week, I had a good chance to read and analyze most of the views several Tech blogs and experts shared about this project. Here are few more details, about Project Glass and with whom my opinion synced well.

Google's concept glasses have a: a) Camera,
b) Microphone,
c) 3G/4G data connection (to send and receive data in rea…